Our city's athletic association transitions to tackle football in 3rd grade. We didn't think Reggie was quite ready for that responsibility, so he (and a friend) signed up for a flag football league in a neighboring city. It was an interesting bit of a culture shift from our city's league. Maybe it was just the team, or the league, but, overall, the experience was less....passionate. I don't know if this was just our experience, or a growing trend in youth sports, but no one seemed very excited about winning.
I think someone was keeping score during the season, and certainly the kids were, but nothing was ever said about the teams winning or losing a game. That's all fine, I'm not saying the winning team should be smug about it. But when it came to the final tournament, although it was much of a side note, the three teams with the highest ranking where scheduled to play two games in a mini-bracket, while all the other teams played one game. I thought, Okay, here we go! Finally, some competitive enthusiasm!
Not so. The games came and went, and Reggie's team won both games, so we concluded the Broncos won the tournament. The stereotypical "everyone gets a trophy" didn't happen. Instead - no one did. But it's not about the trophy. Not even the coach acknowledged the victory - at least not publicly. No one held up a #1 finger when the team posed for their end of season photo op, not even one kid. The league had sponsored an ice cream truck, and even though it was 45 degrees, all the kids had a scoop of ice cream. And then it was done.
Don't get me wrong - I agree youth sports should be about kids having fun, trying new things, and learning to be a team player and a good sport. But it seems like there was such a concern about a nine year old feeling bad about not winning that we couldn't celebrate a job well-done. Isn't there something to be learned from both winning and losing? I see value in both. I see value in placing somewhere in the middle and being proud of what was accomplished. I see value in placing last and saying, "That was a tough break. Let's see what we can do to change that next season" or "Well, maybe football's not your thing. Let's find something that is." And to the winners, "Wow, you worked together, and it paid off. Congratulations!"
Regardless, Reggie had fun, and we enjoyed watching him.
(And they won.)
















